The agency found that Mexican carriers can operate safely.
“FMCSA concludes that the Pilot Program successfully demonstrated that Mexican motor carriers can and do operate throughout the United States at a safety level equivalent to U.S and Canada- domiciled motor carriers and consistent with the high safety standards that FMCSA imposes on all motor carriers authorized to operate in the United States,” the agency said.
The Mexican carriers in the program had much lower driver and vehicle out-of-service rates than U.S. or Canadian carriers.
Their driver OOS rate was 0.2% compared to 5.3% for U.S. carriers and 3.7% for Canadian carriers. Their vehicle OOS rate was 8.9% compared to 22% for U.S. carriers and 12.5% for Canadian carriers.
The agency ended the pilot last October and granted either normal or provisional operating authority to the 13 Mexican carriers that participated in the program.
The agency said that Mexican carriers applying for long-haul authority will have to clear a Pre-Authorization Safety Audit and confirm that they have safety management systems in place. These systems must include hours-of-service monitoring and drug testing.
Mexican drivers must have either a U.S. commercial license or the Mexican equivalent and be proficient in English. Once a carrier is approved to operate across the border, its trucks must clear a North American Standard Level I inspection every 90 days for four years.
14-Year NAFTA Delay The decision to accept Mexican applications closes a chapter in the 14-year U.S. effort to comply with terms of the North American Free Trade Agreement.
Under the agreement, the border should have been opened to long-distance trucking in both directions in 2000. The opening was stalled until 2007 by difficult negotiations with Mexico and opposition from U.S. labor unions and owner-operators who oppose free trade, fear the loss of jobs and argued that Mexican trucking is not safe.
In 2007 the Bush administration started a demonstration program to test a safety regime set up by FMCSA. When Congress killed this program in 2010 Mexico retaliated with $2 billion in import tariffs on agricultural and industrial products.
In 2011 the Obama administration negotiated a deal in which Mexico agreed to drop the tariffs while the U.S. put in place a revised program to vet Mexican carriers for safety. This is the three-year program that ended last October.
“Opening the door to a safe cross-border trucking system with Mexico is a major step forward in strengthening our relationship with the nation’s third largest trading partner, and in meeting our obligations under NAFTA,” said Transportation Secretary Anthony Foxx in a statement.
U.S. Trade Representative Michael Froman said the announcement sets the stage for Mexico to withdraw the threat of tariffs.
“We have been, and will continue to work with Mexico to ensure that the threat of retaliatory duties will now be brought to a swift conclusion,” he said in a statement.
But reaction from labor and owner-operators indicates that the issue is not closed.
When the agency granted authority to the Mexican pilot carriers in October, the Teamsters and the Owner-Operator Independent Drivers Association registered strong objections.
OOIDA Executive Director Todd Spencer indicated that court action against the border opening is an option, and that the group would seek support from members of Congress who oppose the opening.
Opponents of the opening are focusing on an audit of the pilot program by the DOT Inspector General.
The Inspector General confirmed that proper safety controls are in place but added that the program had too few participants to project the outcome of a full border opening.
This shortage of participants is evidence that the pilot program failed, said Teamsters General President Jim Hoffa.
“(The pilot program) did not provide enough data for the (Inspector General) to determine with any confidence that the trucks participating in the program were representative of those that could be permitted in the future,” Hoffa said in a statement.
The agency, on the other hand, says it in fact had plenty of data.
Because the Inspector General’s analysis was restricted to data collected on the program’s carriers, the agency said it also studied safety and inspection data for other long-haul Mexican carriers.
This analysis looked at an additional 952 international carriers that are either Mexican-owned or based in Mexico. Of these, 351 received authority during the three-year program, the agency said.
The agency told Congress that while the Inspector General could not determine if the program participants were representative of Mexican carriers that might apply for long-haul authority, Mexican officials indicated that the program will set the pattern for Mexican carriers' response.